|
Law can be categorised in number of ways although the various
categories are not mutually exclusive
|
|
Common Law – Civil Law Systems
|
|
Common Law And Civil Law
|
-
Common Law and Civil Law; distinct legal systems.
-
The English legal system is a Common Law one as
opposed to Continental systems that are based on Civil Law.
-
Because the Roman codes were almost entirely
limited to the private area, public law is usually not codified.
|
|
Courts In Civil Law Jurisdictions
|
-
In civil-law countries, separate administrative
courts adjudicate claims and disputes between the various branches
of government and citizens, and many lawyers specialise in public
law.
-
In France, Germany, and Italy, still other courts
handle constitutional issues.
|
|
The English Legal System
Civil Law – Criminal
Law
|
|
Comparison |
-
The English legal system is characterised by two
major categories of law, those of CIVIL (not
the same as the Civil Law referred to above)
and CRIMINAL law. Each has its own specific aims and outcomes.
-
The first major comparison is in the DESCRIPTION of
civil and criminal law.
|
|
Civil
|
|
|
Crime
|
-
Essentially an anti – social act against the
state.
-
(R v Jones) R= Regina (Queen)
Rex (King). The state against Jones.
-
As a broad principle, Civil Law seeks to
compensate; criminal to punish.
-
Both attempt to regulate behaviour.
|
|
Civil Law
|
Professor
Winfield's definition.
" A breach of duty fixed by law, towards persons
generally. Its breach redressable by an action for unliquidated
damages".
"Unliquidated" – Not a pre-estimated any amount.
|
Civil Law Duties
|
-
Civil law demands that we do not do certain
things. E.G. Trespass or create a Nuisance or Defame someone's
character.
-
The result is DAMAGES. Note the recent trend for
the courts to compensate for intangible losses, e.g.
"disappointment" if a holiday were to fail Jarvis
v Swantours.
|
|
Interaction –v- Enforcement
|
|
Civil Law Situations
|
Sometimes clear-cut. You’ve been caught on
someone’s land to you must have trespassed. There will be fewer
obstacles in the way of obtaining a remedy. (In crime the mental element
vital to guilt – can be difficult to prove).
This is not to say Civil Law is simpler than Criminal Law both has their
complexities.
|
|
Common Law – Equity
|
|
Common Law and Equity
|
-
Common Law and Equity distinguish the two
historical sources and systems of English Law.
-
Common Law emerged in the process of establishing a
single legal system throughout the country.
-
Equity was developed later to soften the formal
rigour of the Common Law.
-
The two systems are now united but in the final
analysis Equity should prevail.
|
|
Sources
|
-
Common Law and Statute relate to the source of
law.
-
Common Law is judge made:
-
Statute Law is produced by Parliament.
|
|
|
-
Private Law and Public Law relate to whom the law
is addressed.
-
Private Law relates to the individual citizen
whereas
-
Public Law relates to institutions of government.
|
|
Private Law – Public Law
Private Law
|
|
Relationships
|
Private law involves the various relationships that
people have with one another and the rules that determine their legal
rights and duties among themselves. The area is concerned with rules and
principles pertaining to private ownership and use of property,
contracts between individuals, family relationships, and redress by way
of compensation for harm inflicted on one person by another.
|
|
Private arrangements
|
Historically, government involvement was usually
minimal.
Private law has also operated to provide general
guidelines and security in private arrangements and interactions in ways
that are complementary to morality and custom but that are not
necessarily enforceable in a court of law, such as non-contractual
promises and agreements within an association of private individuals.
|
|
Public
Law |
|
Includes
|
Is a term used to describe law concerned with the
state law enforcement.
It includes criminal law, local government law and
town panning Law. The two latter subjects are specialised aspects of
administrative .law.
Contrast public law with private law, e.g. contract.
|
|
Government
Individuals
|
Public law concerns the relationships within
government and those between governments and individuals.
|
|
Taxation
|
Laws concerning taxation and the regulation of
business are in the public area, as is criminal law.
|
|
Criminal Law
|
Criminal law not only promotes security and order but
also reinforces
moral norms.
Debate has been continuous regarding the legitimacy of government
intervention in areas where moral attitudes are in significant conflict,
such as in matters of sexual practices, pornography, birth control, and
euthanasia.
|
|
No constitution
|
Because the Uk has no written constitution, basic
principles pertaining to government powers and limits and to fundamental
individual rights are found in acts of Parliament, judicial opinions,
and tradition.
|
|
Control of resources
|
Public law dominates in government-controlled
societies; democratic societies increasingly have a mix of public and
private law. The private sphere includes individuals and a vast array of
groups, associations, organisations, and special legal entities such as
corporations.
They compete with one another and with government for
control of resources, wealth, power, and the communication of ideas and
values. Special fields of law, such as employment law, facilitate and
control this competition.
Much of such law is in the commercial and corporate
areas. The formerly purely private law of property and contracts, for
example, is now overlaid with legislation, regulations, and judicial
decisions reflecting the competition.
|
|
Administrative
Law
Is a comparatively recent occurrence. |
|
Local Government and Administrative
Agencies
|
Numerous local and government administrative agencies
now make rules that reach into all manner of activities, including
-
Licensing,
-
Regulation of trades and professions,
-
Protection of health,
-
Promotion of welfare.
-
Compulsory purchase,
-
Planning controls,
-
Regulatory controls and determinations like social
security payment
Their powers emanate from legislation, and their rules
are reviewable by the courts.
|
|
Judicial Review
|
This deals with the organisation, powers and duties of
public administrative authorities.
In the modern state the executive has wide powers of.
When the authorities act outside the law, administrative law (hopefully)
has the remedies.
France and Belgium have a special structure (Droit
Administrative). We do not.
|
|
International
Law |
|
Background
|
The legal process that concerns relations among
nations is called international law. Belief and experience in some form
of international law dates from at least the days of the Roman Empire.
Such law differs greatly from national legal systems.
No court has the authority or power to give judgments backed by coercive
sanctions.
|
|
Based on Custom
Treaties and
Conventions
|
Even in its most modern developments, international
law is almost wholly based on custom.
The precedents on which it rests are the acts of
independent governments in their relations with one another, including
treaties and conventions.
Behind many of its rules is only a moral sanction: the
public opinion of the civilised world.
When treaties or conventions are involved, however,
machinery to enforce them exists-either an arbitration or conciliation
procedure or the submission of the dispute to a regional or
international court.
|
|
Definitions
|
A discernible body of rules and principles is observed or at least
acknowledged in international relations.
These rules concern such matters as territorial titles and boundaries,
use of the high seas, limits on war, telecommunication, diplomatic and
consular exchange, and use of air space.
|
|
|
The major sources of international law on these
matters are multilateral treaties, international custom, and such
general principles as are recognised by civilised nations.
|
|
United Nations
|
The United Nations is one of the primary mechanisms
that articulate and create international law.
The General Assembly and other agencies of the UN
bring a combination of diplomacy, negotiation, and propaganda to bear on
World affairs in ways that produce effective international treaties and
affect world opinion.
Certain courts also have indirect impact, including
the International Court of Justice. Domestic courts in various nations
at times also engage in the articulation of international law.
|